martes, 14 de marzo de 2017

Feminists should wake up to the dangers of transgenderism | MercatorNet

Feminists should wake up to the dangers of transgenderism

Feminists should wake up to the dangers of transgenderism

Feminists should wake up to the dangers of transgenderism

As women, we have the right to protest against the view that our bodies no longer matter.
Giselle Bertino-Clarke | Mar 14 2017 | comment 

Last month, the UK Girl Guides opened their membership to any “person who self-identifies” as a female. Julie Bentley, Chief Executive of Girlguiding previously praised the Guides as “the ultimate feminist organisation.”
This comes after National Geographic published a special issue of the iconic magazine, themed the “Gender Revolution” and featuring Avery Jackson, a 9-year-old transgender girl on the front cover, sporting long pink hair and an all-pink outfit.
The magazine attempts to normalise gender dysphoria through the emotional stories of several gender non-conforming individuals across the globe.
In one article, author Robin Marantz Henig describes a teenage girl planning to transition into a male: “She has always felt more boyish than girlish. From an early age, E, as she prefers to be called for this story, hated wearing dresses, liked basketball, skateboarding, [and] video games.”
Bruce Jenner, now famously known as Caitlyn Jenner, said of his transition that “the hardest thing about being a woman is figuring out what to wear.”
To tell the truth, every woman should feel insulted by such remarks, which reduce femininity to mere physical appearance and a preference for traditionally feminine activities – femininity as seen through a man’s eyes. Yet the transgender lobby continues to push this type of narrative.
Renowned radical feminists, Germaine Greer and Sheila Jeffreys have publicly criticised transgenderism, arguing that it reinforces traditional sexist stereotypes.
Unsurprisingly, they have been vilified for their “transphobic,” “outdated” and “bigoted” views. It is disturbing that men, wishing to be recognised as female, are singlehandedly redefining the feminine identity and silencing any woman who rejects these infringements on their own sex.
What could be more misogynistic than this? But why aren’t other feminists jumping to their defence? Where are the women who so furiously marched against President Trump’s attitudes towards women? Where are they now with their “No Uterus, No Opinion” signs?
No doubt, some are afraid to face the wrath of the LGBT community. However, many remain absent from the debate because, in fighting for women’s rights, they hold that there are no biological differences between men and women. Therefore, they cannot defend their womanhood without admitting that the sexes are indeed distinct.
Consequently, this has reduced the definition of what it means to be a man or woman to shallow understandings of gender. That is: “I think I am a woman because I like fashion and pretty things.”
The body then becomes a mere entity forced to conform to the sex that one “identifies” with. Erasing biology, which is a crucial aspect of our womanhood, has allowed the transgender movement to hijack our feminine identity.
Bruce Jenner will never experience what it truly means to be a woman. No amount of cosmetic surgery and cross-sex hormones will help him achieve that. He will never deal with a monthly menstrual cycle, feel new life grow within him, bear the historical weight of inequality or carry a deep sense of pride in our victories for women’s rights. And yet, there is so much more to womanhood. As Diane Mariechild beautifully wrote, “A woman is the full circle. Within her is the power to create, nurture and transform.” No man can ever partake in the mystery of feminine identity.
I do not doubt for a second that, deep down, Jenner and Jackson know this. And that will forever be their tragedy: men can never become women, and women can never become men. “Rather, they become feminised men or masculinised women,” according to Dr Paul McHugh, former psychiatrist in chief at Johns Hopkins Hospital, the originators of sexual reassignment surgery. They have distorted their bodies to pursue a lie.
It is heartbreaking that some men and women have subjected themselves to such aggressive and radical medical procedures, because they feel that they cannot live up to society’s unrealistic standards of masculinity and femininity.
That doctors and health professionals have encouraged such measures to be undertaken is to be deplored. We have collectively failed as a society to help those who experience gender dysphoria to love and celebrate the beautiful bodies and unique personalities they have all been gifted with.
We must not let the LGBT community bully us into complying. As women, we have the right to protest against the view that our bodies no longer matter.
We must call on society to uphold our right to privacy and protect against men invading our bathrooms, change rooms and any other designated spaces for women and girls. In doing so, we must take care to treat transgender individuals with the utmost dignity, love and respect. But that does not mean we must play along with the charade.
Feminists must wake up and set their differences aside to defend the dignity and rights of women. For as Virginia Woolf insightfully warned: “Anything may happen when womanhood has ceased to be a protected occupation.” Quite literally, it has. 
Giselle Bertino-Clarke is Education Officer at the Life, Marriage & Family Centre, an agency of the Catholic Archdiocese of Sydney. This article has been republished from The Catholic Weekly (Sydney) with permission. 
- See more at:


One of the most tedious words in the English language is “equality”. Racial equality, gender equality, marriage equality, economic equality – the chatter about these pious goals is endless. Yet all the while, new inequalities are born.
In our lead article today Jennifer Johnson talks about the real and distressing inequality that she, and many like her, experienced growing up in a broken family – and that many children continue to experience in ways undreamed of at the beginning of the sexual revolution that made it all possible. Until we begin seriously to address this inequality, which causes children so much suffering, we should cease and desist from talking about any other.
A word about the feature asking whether humanity should colonise other planets, assuming it becomes possible. We have run the piece because provides an interesting survey of the literature and film on this theme and poses a valid question. The answer, however, is not one we would agree with – at least not for the reasons given, which suggest a rather low view of our species. We look forward to your comments.
And a STOP PRESS: The editor has just forwarded me an AP story headed, “US applications for New Zealand citizenship jump 70 percent”. I am sure you can guess the reason, and it’s not just our majestic mountains. You can read the details for yourself here.

Carolyn Moynihan
Deputy Editor,

Family diversity and its children: the next equality debate
By Jennifer Johnson
Changes in marriage and family life result in inequality for children.
Read the full article
Extinction or survival: how storytellers explore the ethics of colonising other planets
By Siobhan Lyons
It may be possible, but does that mean we should?
Read the full article
‘Jackie’ treads the thin line between fact and memory
By Luisa Cotta Ramosino
In a brilliant performance, Natalie Portman portrays a woman who tries to reshape history
Read the full article
Feminists should wake up to the dangers of transgenderism
By Giselle Bertino-Clarke
As women, we have the right to protest against the view that our bodies no longer matter.
Read the full article
Novel examines social challenges of pre-teens
By Jennifer Minicus
Starting middle school can be nerve-wracking.
Read the full article
The assisted suicide project will never end
By Paul Russell
Its supporters will always find new borders to cross and new rules to transgress
Read the full article
America dulls its pain and shortens life spans
By Marcus Roberts
Another largely unremarked crisis: opiates.
Read the full article
The prehistory of the Alt-right
By Jeffrey Tucker
The new movement has some very unsavoury progenitors
Read the full article
The Netherlands wants to fund abortions in Africa
By Mathew Otieno
Meanwhile a famine threatens the lives of 20 million people there.
Read the full article
Women do have power in the world of work, UN please note
By Vincenzina Santoro
Many women have advanced beyond 'equality' in their professions.
Read the full article

MERCATORNET | New Media Foundation
Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George Street, North Strathfied NSW 2137, Australia

Designed by elleston

New Media Foundation | Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605 

No hay comentarios: