sábado, 29 de abril de 2017

BioEdge: Where did Nazi doctors learn their ethics? From a textbook

BioEdge: Where did Nazi doctors learn their ethics? From a textbook

Saturday, April 29, 2017



Where did Nazi doctors learn their ethics? From a textbook
     
Karl Brandt, one of the defendants in the "doctors' trial"   
German medicine under Hitler resulted in so many horrors – eugenics, human experimentation, forced sterilization, involuntary euthanasia, mass murder – that there is a temptation to say that “Nazi doctors had no ethics”.

However, according to an article in the Annals of Internal Medicine by Florian Bruns and Tessa Chelouche (from Germany and Israel respectively), this was not the case at all. In fact, medical ethics was an important part of the medical curriculum between 1939 and 1945. Nazi officials established lectureships in every medical school in Germany for a subject called “Medical Law and Professional Studies” (MLPS).

There was no lack of ethics. It was just the wrong kind of ethics.

The focus of their study is a Rudolf Ramm, a German general practitioner who became the pre-eminent purveyor of Nazi medical ethics. He was editor-in-chief of the journal of the German Medical Association, Deutsches Ärzteblatt, and published a textbook, Ärztliche Rechts- Standeskunde (Medical Law and Health). The textbook sold out within a year. Ramm did not survive to be a defendant in the famous “doctors trial” in 1947. He was tried and shot by the Soviets in August 1945. His book was banned a few months later.

What did medical students learn during the Nazi era? According to Bruns and Chelouche, it was “the unequal worth of human beings, the moral imperative of preserving a pure Aryan people, the authoritarian role of the physician, the individual's obligation to stay healthy, and the priority of public health over individual-patient care”.

Ramm taught his students that:

Nazism brought the “reinstatement of a high level of professional ethics.” He welcomed the fact that “the profession had been extensively cleansed of politically unreliable elements foreign to our race” (that is, German-Jewish physicians).

Ramm saw 3 distinct dangers facing the German people: “racial miscegenation,” a declining birthrate, and the “growth of inferior elements” in the German population. He traced the origins of these perceived dangers to a “disregard for the laws of nature,” caused by church dogma and socialist ideologies. Ramm denounced any form of health care for “hereditarily inferior” people and asserted that every person in Nazi Germany had a moral duty to stay healthy.

After this brief survey, Bruns and Chelouche argue that today’s doctors must resist the temptation to believe that they are much more ethical than “the bad old days”. A commitment to ethics can wax and wane. In fact, in the Weimar Republic, the ethical standards for human experimentation were “remarkably advanced”. The Nazis did not even bother to repeal them, but simply redefined the subject of experimentation to exclude concentration camp inmates. They conclude by warning that:

It is important to realize that ethical reasoning can be corrupted and that teaching ethics is, in itself, no guarantee of the moral integrity of physicians. The history of bioethics reveals that the professional ethos of physicians is more fragile than we might believe because it depends on the moral zeitgeist and politico-social circumstances, both of which are subject to change ...


Bioedge

Saturday, April 29, 2017

The Belgian media was abuzz this week with the news that the Catholic hospitals which provide a substantial portion of psychiatric beds will permit euthanasia for non-terminally-ill patients. It is an unprecedented reversal of their stand on end-of-life care.
Supporters of euthanasia, of course, were delighted. “The last relics of the paternalism of the shepherd have been replaced by individual self-determination," said one politician. Opponents, however, were puzzled and alarmed. Fifteen years after Belgium legalised euthanasia, it has become hard to find a hospital where is it not being practised. Read about it below. 


Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge

NEWS THIS WEEK
 
by Michael Cook | Apr 29, 2017
From now on it will be difficult to find a psychiatric hospital where euthanasia is not offered
 
by Michael Cook | Apr 29, 2017
US researchers are close to an artificial womb for extremely premature babies
 
by Michael Cook | Apr 29, 2017
Life expectancy has risen steeply
 
by Michael Cook | Apr 29, 2017
Why should they settle for anything less than heterosexual couples?
 
by Michael Cook | Apr 29, 2017
There was no lack of ethical training in the Nazi era
 
by Paul Russell | Apr 27, 2017
Ezekiel Emanuel says that pain is not the the reason people ask doctors to end their lives
 
by Michael Cook | Apr 26, 2017
Ellinor Grimmark has had to move to Norway to find work
BioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
New Media Foundation | Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605 

BioEdge: Where did Nazi doctors learn their ethics? From a textbook

LOS MARGINADOS y "el dispreciau", [https://wwweldispreciau.blogspot.com.ar] by Cerasale Morteo, Víctor Norberto | SALTA | ARGENTINA | 2008-2017 | una conjunción de voluntades para sostener en alto la DIGNIDAD HUMANA y los HUMANISMOS NECESARIOS que dan sentido a la vida en todas sus formas [ABRIL - 4 | 29 de abril de 2017]

LOS MARGINADOS y "el dispreciau", [https://wwweldispreciau.blogspot.com.ar] by Cerasale Morteo, Víctor Norberto | SALTA | ARGENTINA | 2008-2017 | una conjunción de voluntades para sostener en alto la DIGNIDAD HUMANA y los HUMANISMOS NECESARIOS que dan sentido a la vida en todas sus formas [ABRIL - 4 | 29 de abril de 2017]

MARRUECOS DENUNCIA AUTORIDADES ARGELINAS | La Voz del Árabe
MARRUECOS DENUNCIA AUTORIDADES ARGELINAS
La Voz del Árabe

Marruecos lamenta la dramática situación de inmigrantes sirios en territorio argelino y denuncia comportamientos inhumanos de las autoridades argelinas…
LAVOZDELARABE.COM.MX
MARRUECOS DENUNCIA AUTORIDADES ARGELINAS | La Voz del Árabe
LOGO LA VOZ DEL ARABE

Archivo del blog




¿POR QUÉ EEUU BOMBARDEÓ LA BASE AÉREA EN SIRIA? / Por Rosa María Salazar
Porque quería usar el elemento sorpresa para fortalecer su capacidad de negociar con los rusos, chinos, norcoreanos, egipcios, con los israelíes; y en Estados Unidos con legisladores de ambas cámaras.
La Voz del Árabe

Porque quería usar el elemento sorpresa para fortalecer su capacidad de negociar con los rusos, chinos, norcoreanos, egipcios, con los israelíes; y en Estados…
LAVOZDELARABE.COM.MX
¿POR QUÉ EEUU BOMBARDEÓ LA BASE AÉREA EN SIRIA? | La Voz del Árabe
LOGO LA VOZ DEL ARABE


Archivo del blog


Archivo del blog



LOS MARGINADOS y "el dispreciau", [https://wwweldispreciau.blogspot.com.ar] by Cerasale Morteo, Víctor Norberto | SALTA | ARGENTINA | 2008-2017 | una conjunción de voluntades para sostener en alto la DIGNIDAD HUMANA y los HUMANISMOS NECESARIOS que dan sentido a la vida en todas sus formas [ABRIL - 2 | 15 de abril de 2017]


MÉXICO SE UNE A LA SEMANA DEL APARTHEID ISRAELÍ / Por: Ana Rosa Moreno
MÉXICO SE UNE A LA SEMANA DEL APARTHEID ISRAELÍ | La Voz del Árabe
Con motivo de la 13ª Semana del Apartheid Israelí se llevarán a cabo entre marzo y abril actividades en más de 225 ciudades alrededor del mundo.
La Voz del Árabe




Con motivo de la 13ª Semana del Apartheid Israelí se llevarán a cabo entre marzo y abril actividades en más de 225 ciudades alrededor del mundo.
LAVOZDELARABE.COM.MX

MÉXICO SE UNE A LA SEMANA DEL APARTHEID ISRAELÍ | La Voz del Árabe
LOGO LA VOZ DEL ARABE

Archivo del blog


LOS MARGINADOS y "el dispreciau", [https://wwweldispreciau.blogspot.com.ar] by Cerasale Morteo, Víctor Norberto | SALTA | ARGENTINA | 2008-2017 | una conjunción de voluntades para sostener en alto la DIGNIDAD HUMANA y los HUMANISMOS NECESARIOS que dan sentido a la vida en todas sus formas [ABRIL - 1 | 08 de abril de 2017]


EL TALENTO DE YASMINA KHADRA / Por: Laura Tejeda Meza
No somos perezosos. Sólo nos tomamos el tiempo para vivir. Lo cual, no es el caso de los occidentales. Para ellos el tiempo es dinero.




No somos perezosos. Sólo nos tomamos el tiempo para vivir. Lo cual, no es el caso de los occidentales. Para ellos el tiempo es dinero.
LAVOZDELARABE.COM.MX


LOGO LA VOZ DEL ARABE
EL TALENTO DE YASMINA KHADRA | La Voz del Árabe
.-.-.-.-.-.-.


Archivo del blog


.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.


Mi devoción eterna

Mi devoción eterna
Virgen de Schoenstatt (tres veces admirable)


Santuario de la Virgen Schoenstatt

Santuario de la Virgen Schoenstatt
sin condiciones (para ella todo: "se te ha dado gratuitamente, debes dar de igual forma")
.-.-.-.-.-.-.
PERIODISTA ÁRABE ISRAELÍ, LUCY AHARISH, PIDE EN TELEVISIÓN ACABAR CON EL “HOLOCAUSTO” EN SIRIA
Aharish, muy dura con la comunidad internacional y la ciudadanía por su pasividad, llama "hipócrita" a la ONU y se declara "avergonzada"…
La Voz del Árabe

PERIODISTA ÁRABE ISRAELÍ, LUCY AHARISH, PIDE EN TELEVISIÓN ACABAR CON EL “HOLOCAUSTO” EN SIRIA | La Voz del Árabe


LOGO LA VOZ DEL ARABE